Homeschooling Picker Kayla Divorce: Why She Split with Jonathan

Breakups are never easy, and when a couple has been together for almost 20 years, it’s even harder. That’s why so many fans were shocked when Homeschooling Picker Kayla and Jonathan Jose Llamas split. People had questions—what happened? Why did they break up? And how is Kayla doing now?

What we do know is that their marriage ended in early 2023, and by mid-year, Kayla was in a new relationship with fellow reseller Matt from Part Time Pickers. They seemed happy together, but some fans weren’t sure how to feel about it.

So, curious to know Homeschooling Picker Kayla divorce reason? Then, keep reading. In this blog, we’ll break down everything—their relationship timeline, why they split, Kayla’s new romance, and how fans reacted. Stick around, because there’s a lot to unpack!

Key Points

• Kayla and Jonathan were together for almost 20 years before their divorce.
• They have two daughters, one in college and one still at home.
• The divorce was finalized in early 2023, and fans started noticing changes.
• They may have grown apart, and Kayla’s busy career could have been a factor.
• Kayla started dating Matt from Part Time Pickers just a few months later.
• Jonathan has stayed off social media, and no one knows if he’s dating.
• Fans had mixed feelings—some were shocked, while others supported her.
• Kayla’s business is still growing, and she seems to be in a good place.

Homeschooling Picker Kayla Divorce

Kayla, widely known as The Homeschooling Picker, has been a favorite in the reselling and homeschooling community for years. Her content, which focuses on balancing homeschooling with eBay reselling, has gained a dedicated following. 

But in 2023, fans started noticing changes—there were fewer mentions of her husband, Jonathan Jose Llamas, in her videos. Eventually, it was confirmed: Homeschooling Picker Kayla and Jonathan had divorced after nearly two decades of marriage.

She hasn’t shared every detail about why they split. Their eldest daughter had already graduated from college in May 2023, but their younger daughter is still in her teens, which means co-parenting is still part of their lives. 

Divorce is tough, especially when kids are involved, but Kayla has kept things moving. She’s still homeschooling, still reselling, and still showing up for her audience.

Homeschooling Picker Kayla Divorce Update

Since her divorce, Homeschooling Picker Kayla has kept herself busy, and her content has changed a bit. There’s been less talk about homeschooling and more focus on reselling and business. That makes sense—she’s adapting to a new chapter in her life.

One of the biggest updates? She’s in a new relationship. In June 2023, she confirmed that she’s dating Matt from Part Time Pickers, another reseller and YouTuber (more on it later).

Homeschooling Picker Kayla Divorce Date

Homeschooling Picker Kayla hasn’t given an exact date for her divorce, but based on what’s been shared publicly, it looks like her marriage ended in early 2023. Around that time, fans noticed her content shifting, and by May, her eldest daughter had graduated college, marking a big life change for the family.

Then, by June 2023, she and Matt went public with their relationship. That makes it pretty clear that her divorce was finalized before then. It’s been a year of big changes for her, but she seems to be finding her rhythm again.

Homeschooling Picker Kayla Divorce Settlement

Homeschooling Picker Kayla hasn’t talked about the details of her divorce settlement, and honestly, that’s not surprising. Some things are just personal, and she’s never been one to overshare when it comes to her private life.

What we do know is that she’s doing fine financially. As of 2024, her net worth is estimated to be around $250,000, thanks to her YouTube channel and eBay business. If the divorce affected her financially, she hasn’t let it slow her down.

Much like Kayla’s situation, JD Harmeyer’s divorce had its own twists and surprises. If you’re curious about his story, here are the key details.

Homeschooling Picker Kayla Divorce Reasons

Homeschooling Picker Kayla and Jonathan haven’t publicly shared the exact reason behind their divorce. It seems their relationship slowly changed over time. Like many long-term marriages, theirs may have faced challenges that eventually made it impossible to continue.

Reason 1: Irreconcilable Differences

Homeschooling Picker Kayla and Jonathan had been together for almost 20 years, and over time, their priorities, interests, or even ways of thinking may have shifted. Marriage is a partnership, and if two people no longer see eye to eye on the most important things, it can become tough to keep the relationship going.

It’s common for long-term couples to try everything before calling it quits, especially when they have kids. But if the differences between them become too big to ignore, staying together can feel more like a battle than a marriage.

Reason 2: Long-Term Relationship Strain

Being in a marriage for nearly two decades is a huge commitment. Over time, stress, routine, and changing goals can take a toll on any relationship. Even in strong marriages, couples sometimes struggle with communication, emotional connection, or just feeling like they’re on the same page.

For Kayla and Jonathan, raising kids, running a household, and balancing their personal goals may have put pressure on their relationship. 

Reason 3: Career Priorities

Kayla’s YouTube channel and reselling business have taken off over the past few years. She has dedicated a lot of time to filming, editing, sourcing products, and engaging with her growing audience. While success is exciting, it also requires a lot of time and energy—sometimes at the expense of personal relationships.

Just like Kayla’s divorce, Yolanda Hadid and David’s breakup had people wondering what really went down. Get the latest details on their split here.

Who is Homeschooling Picker Kayla Dating After Divorce?

Kayla has officially moved on from her divorce and is now dating fellow reseller and YouTuber, Matt from Part Time Pickers. The two went public with their relationship in June 2023, and since then, they’ve been pretty much inseparable. 

Fans had been speculating for a while since they were appearing in each other’s videos more often. Turns out, both of them went through divorces around the same time, and that shared experience brought them closer. They’ve been working together a lot, and from the looks of it, they’re really happy.

Matt and Kayla share a lot of common interests, which probably helped bring them together. They’re both passionate about reselling, thrifting, and creating content for their audiences. Since both of them went through divorces around the same time, they also understand the challenges of starting over.

If you follow Kayla’s YouTube channel, you’ll notice that Matt appears in almost every video now. On January 14, 2024, she even posted a cute video where they both made a mistake while filming, and fans loved seeing their playful dynamic. 

A few days earlier, on January 10, they were spotted enjoying the snow together, which only fueled more excitement from their followers. They aren’t just business partners—they genuinely seem to enjoy each other’s company.

Is Jonathan Jose Llamas Dating Anyone After Divorce From Kayla?

Unlike Kayla, Jonathan has kept a much lower profile since the divorce. While Kayla has been sharing her journey with her audience, Jonathan has stayed out of the spotlight, leading to a lot of curiosity about his personal life. As of now, there’s no public confirmation that he is dating anyone new.

Whether he’s dating or not, Jonathan is likely navigating this new phase in his life at his own pace. And while Kayla has been more open about her post-divorce journey, Jonathan appears to be taking a more private approach.

If Kayla’s story caught your attention, you might also want to read about Danielle Eilers’ divorce. It’s another case that has sparked a lot of discussion.

Homeschooling Picker Kayla and Jonathan Jose Llamas Relationship Timeline

Kayla and Jonathan Jose Llamas were together for nearly two decades before they decided to go their separate ways. They built a life together, raising two daughters while navigating the ups and downs of marriage. Their relationship saw many milestones, from early love to raising a family and eventually, parting ways. Below is a timeline of their journey.

Year	Event
Early 2000s	Kayla and Jonathan meet and start dating
2003-2004	The couple gets married
Mid-2000s	They welcome their first daughter
Late 2000s	Their second daughter is born
2010s	Kayla starts focusing on homeschooling their kids
2018-2020	Kayla starts her YouTube journey as The Homeschooling Picker
2022	Subtle changes hint at marital struggles
Early 2023	Divorce rumors begin spreading
Mid-2023	Kayla and Jonathan officially separate
June 2023	Kayla confirms her relationship with Matt from Part Time Pickers

Kayla and Jonathan were married for nearly 20 years, building a life that revolved around family, homeschooling, and later, Kayla’s reselling business. Over time, priorities may have shifted, and their relationship seemed to face challenges that eventually led to their separation.

The divorce wasn’t sudden—it appeared to be a gradual process. Fans started noticing changes in Kayla’s content in early 2023, and by mid-year, it became clear that she and Jonathan had gone their separate ways. Despite the split, they continue to co-parent their teenage daughter, showing that their focus remains on family, even if they are no longer together.

Homeschooling Picker Kayla and Matt Net Worth

Both Kayla and Matt have built successful careers as YouTubers and resellers. Kayla, with her Homeschooling Picker brand, earns through YouTube ad revenue, sponsorships, and eBay reselling. As of 2024, her net worth is estimated to be around $250,000, a result of years of dedication to her online business.

Matt, known for Part Time Pickers, has also made a name for himself in the reselling world. While his exact net worth isn’t public, estimates suggest he is worth between $300,000 and $400,000. Together, they make a strong team, frequently collaborating and leveraging their platforms for greater success. Their relationship isn’t just personal—it also enhances their professional growth, making them one of the most popular reseller couples online.

Fans Reaction to Homeschooling Picker Kayla Divorce

When Kayla and Jonathan’s divorce became public, fans had mixed reactions. Some were shocked, others were supportive, and a few were even skeptical about how quickly Kayla moved on. While many appreciated her honesty and strength, others couldn’t help but express their concerns.

Shocked and Sad Fans

Some fans had been following Kayla for years and saw her family as an example of homeschooling success. Seeing her marriage end left them surprised and even a little heartbroken.

Fan Comments:

• “I never expected this! They seemed so solid.”
• “I feel like I watched their family grow… this is really sad.”
• “Divorce is never easy, especially after 20 years. Wishing them both peace.”
• “This just makes me realize that we never really know what’s happening behind the scenes.”
• “I hope their kids are handling it okay. That’s always the hardest part.”
• “So many marriages fell apart in 2023… it’s crazy.”
• “Not gonna lie, this makes me sad. I always thought they were the perfect family.”
• “I hope they both find happiness, but this is a tough one to hear.”
• “Wow… I guess change is part of life, but it still hurts to see.”
• “I never saw this coming. What a shock!”

Supportive Fans

While some were surprised, others fully supported Kayla. They admired her strength, her honesty, and the way she kept pushing forward despite personal struggles.

Fan Comments:

• “If she’s happier now, that’s all that matters.”
• “She’s handling this with grace. Not everyone does.”
• “It takes courage to leave a long marriage. Wishing her and her family the best.”
• “People change, life happens. I support her all the way!”
• “She’s proving that you can keep going even when life changes. Love her strength!”

Skeptical Fans – Questioning the Timeline

Some fans raised eyebrows at how quickly she moved on with Matt. Since she announced her new relationship in June 2023, just months after her divorce, a few followers questioned whether there was overlap.

Fan Comments:

• “Wait… didn’t she just get divorced? That was fast.”
• “I love Kayla, but I can’t lie… this timeline feels a little rushed.”
• “Divorces take time. Makes me wonder when they actually split.”
• “Moving on quickly doesn’t mean she cheated, but it does feel sudden.”
• “I hope she took time to heal before jumping into another relationship.”
• “Matt and Kayla make a great couple, but I can’t help but wonder…”
• “I get that people move on, but I wish she talked more about how she processed everything.”
• “This whole situation seems a little… rushed?”
• “Not judging, but two decades of marriage and a new boyfriend within months? Hmm.”
• “I still support her, but I do wonder about the timeline.”

Fans Loving Kayla and Matt Together

Despite some skepticism, many fans absolutely love her and Matt as a couple. Their chemistry, shared interests, and playful energy have won over a lot of people.

Fan Comments:

• “Kayla and Matt are seriously the cutest reseller couple!”
• “They seem so happy together. I love watching their videos!”
• “They just get each other. You can tell they have a real connection.”
• “Both went through divorces around the same time, so it makes sense that they bonded.”
• “I was skeptical at first, but now I totally see why they work!”
• “If they’re happy, I’m happy! Wishing them all the best.”
• “I love how natural they are together. Their energy is amazing.”
• “Matt and Kayla are literally a reseller power couple!”
• “Forget the past, they look so good together!”

In short, some people were shocked, others were skeptical, but many just wanted to see her happy.

Conclusion

Kayla’s life has changed a lot, as divorce isn’t easy. If you’re looking for the big takeaways, here they are:

• Homeschooling Picker Kayla and Jonathan were married for nearly 20 years before they divorced in early 2023.
• They grew apart over time, and Kayla’s growing reselling business may have played a role.
• Kayla is now dating Matt from Part Time Pickers, and they seem really happy together.
• Jonathan has stayed private, and it’s unclear if he’s seeing anyone.
• Fans had mixed reactions, but many just want Kayla to be happy.

Life moves on, and so has Kayla. She’s proving that even after big changes, happiness and success are still possible.